This supports what you are saying too.enjenjo wrote:This is an old wives tale with all due respect. Some years ago I was involved with a materials study with the engineers in the company I worked for to see if we should stock both grade 5 and grade 8 bolts for use on our heavy trucks. What we found was that a grade 5 bolt would bend, and shear before a grade 8 bolt would even bend. Also before the grade 8 bolt would shear, it would deform the hole it was in by about 30% before shearing in mild steel while a grade 5 bolt the hole would deform by less than 10% to the shear point. All this testing was done with 1/2 inch 13 thread bolts as this was the most common bolt size for us.Gojeep wrote:A higher grade is not always better as less flex and can shear instead due to being more brittle.
Best to do whatever was there OEM.
The second thing we found was that the correct bolt torque was very important to to ultimate strength. Under-torquing by 30% reduced the shear strength by half. Also having threads of the bolt in the shear zone reduced the bolt strength to less than that of the next size smaller bolt.
http://www.industrialchassisinc.com/kil ... de-5-bolt/